Archive for the 'Meditation' Category
Saturday, January 3rd, 2009
I was just remembering a scene from Ram Das’ Be Here Now. I don’t know if I’ve remembered it correctly since I haven’t read the book in over 20 years.
I think most people who quote the title of that book as if it were a prescription for living haven’t read it… but that’s besides the point, which relates to my memory:
In this scene, Ram Das has just come back from India where he had spent time with his guru, Neem Karoli Baba, and was fully engaged in his “japa” practice — repeating a mantra over and over and over and over. Mr. Das (or does he prefer the more hairdresserly Mr. Ram?) recounted (rather, I’m recounting him recounting) being in the car with his father and all that was happening is his mind was the mantra, over and over. All thoughts were subsumed by the mantra. He could barely hear his father through the mantra. And he was blissed out as he rode the waves that the mantra created in his mind.
I was recalling this story because for the last few hours I’ve had the exact same experience!
Every thought, feeling, sensation, experience has merely been taken over by, eaten by, swallowed whole by the musical sound resonating and reverberating through my mind.
Vacuuming becomes the sound.
Talking with people who came to buy my inversion table and gravity boots (thank you Craigslist) becomes the sound.
Eating is like eating the sound.
No thing happens in my mind that doesn’t feel equal to the sound… of ABBA’s Dancing Queen (thank you Meryl Streep in Mama Mia).
I’m not dancing around the living room like Meryl on her Greek Isle, but the rapture is no less technicolor.
Seriously, without the idea that “I have a song stuck in my head, especially a bubble-gum 70’s song that I wish would leave,” how is this any different than repeating some collection of Sanskrit syllables? (Can syllables actually be Sanskrit?)
Quoting one of the advanced spiritual teachings from my Swedish guru group, “With a bit of rock music, everything is fine…”
Posted in Meditation, New Age, Spiritual Growth | 22 Comments »
Monday, December 1st, 2008
Just a quick announcement:
I’ve launched an additional blog at http://www.MeditationTruth.com
Some of you may know that I had a 30+ year meditation practice that I gave up cold turkey one day (the story of why is at http://www.meditationtruth.com/a-modern-look-at-meditation-how-to-meditate-and-meditating-science/) and then ended up developing the Instant Advanced Meditation Course.
Well, to add a bit of focus to meditation, I started MeditationTruth.com
I’m hoping that my sideways look at meditation begins a bigger conversation about meditation practices, the goals and benefits of meditation, and the science (or lack thereof) of meditation.
In fact, if you check out the site and want to contribute, you’ll find a link to use to do so! I want lots of people in on the conversation.
Oh, and so you know, I’ve set up the site to “grow” over the next month. I’ve got about 60 articles in the queue with new content posting every day.
Enjoy.
(and now back to our regularly scheduled bitching and moaning…)
Posted in Meditation | 1 Comment »
Wednesday, September 24th, 2008
Life is like a bowl of cherries.
NOT.
I just walked outside and life was in no way like a bowl of cherries. In fact, it was so unlike a bowl of cherries I can’t even list the differences between life and a bowl of cherries.
All the world’s a stage…
Ummm… not really.
As far as I can tell, the world does not exist in a theater, there’s no audience whining about how “People used to get DRESSED to come to the theater.” No scalpers outside the world giving people access for a hefty “surcharge,” and no intermission.
Now, I know you don’t believe these metaphors are literal. But, man, I’m getting tired of spiritual sales-people who don’t know when they SHOULD be using a metaphor or, worse, don’t know when they ARE using one.
My more specific bitch-and-moan of the day refers to the use of the utterly meaningless phrases: “Your True Nature” and “Who you REALLY are.”
Want to fill a room with eager-to-spend-money spiritual seekers? It’s simple. Tell them that, in your presence, thanks to your woo-woo technique, or due to the grace of your guru they can “experience their true nature,” and “discover who they REALLY are.”
We all have a sense that something’s not quite right in our inner Denmark, and these phrases offer the promise of making it all okay.
Frankly, once you make this sales pitch, you could take money from the people that show up, keep them in a stuffy hotel room for 48 hours straight, do NOTHING else and, guaranteed, some people would end up giving you testimonials like, “I released thousands of years of karma, got my chakras spinning at an octave of the frequency of the universe, reclaimed my soul energy from 2,300,000.38 past lives, and met my soul mate… oh, and I discovered who I really am. I give this workshop 4 Pleadian stars! Two chi-filled thumbs up!”
But, if you feel guilty taking money for letting people have a weekend projection-fest, here’s what you do instead to assuage your guilt (and win this episode of American Guru-Idol):
1) Lead them to a paradoxical experience
2) Tell them that what they’re experiencing is THEIR TRUE NATURE, who they REALLY are
Don’t know how to do #1? Then, see a urologist.
(Sorry, I was channeling Bart Simpson for a moment.)
Here’s how to give someone a paradoxical experience. It’s simple. Give them these instructions:
a) Look straight ahead.
b) Place your hands near your ears; about 2-3 inches away from the side of your head.
c) Notice that BASED ON WHAT YOU SEE in front of you, you have no hands. You can see your elbows, you can see your forearms, but because your hands are behind your eyes, you can’t see them. It’s as if they’ve disappeared into space.
So far this is pretty straightforward, right? I mean, it’s not news to you that you can’t see something that you’re not looking at, is it? It doesn’t keep you up at night that you can’t see the back of your head, does it?
Okay, here’s the “paradoxical part”:
d) Now notice that you are aware of the “space” where your hands are.
e) Without moving your eyes or head, look for the location of that awareness. Notice that “the part of you which is aware of seeing” seems to be in the same space as your now-invisible hands.
All you’ve done there is looked at something physical, so you know how to look. Then you used that same tool to “look” for something that isn’t a “thing.” It’s not possible to see a not-thing. Trying to do so creates a neat, spacious feeling, a paradoxical experience. A “feeling of knowing” without an object.
Okay, ready to lock your attendees into your new religion? Proclaim: “That spaciousness is WHO YOU REALLY ARE. That is your TRUE NATURE.”
Bow to the applause, put out the collection plate and take your saffron robes to the dry-cleaner.
Let’s check this out again, in slow motion. TRYING to LOOK at something you cannot see can generate a feeling of spaciousness, of emptiness. Realizing, then, that you cannot see your SELF transfers that feeling of spaciousness and emptiness to your sense of “me.”
The idea that this IS who you are, or that’s the TRUTH of you… is just a metaphor (and not even a good one).
Our 100,000+ year old brains are constantly searching for the answer to the question, “What do I need to do in order to be happy in the future?” Tell people that their suffering comes from not knowing who they REALLY are and convince them that a paradoxical experience is the TRUTH, and you’ve got a new seeker. Give them a more elaborate cosmology to go with the experience and you’ve got a convert.
The more accurate way to describe the experience would be, “When you look for yourself, doesn’t it SEEM LIKE you are invisible, spacious and empty? Doesn’t it SEEM AS IF you are a big void?”
If you say that, though, people will respond, “Well, yes, it seems that way. That’s interesting and cool, I guess.”
But, for experiencing a metaphor or an analogy, nobody will reach into their wallets to buy your books and CDs, they won’t come back the next week complaining that they LOST the experience of who they really are and need you to give them another hit, they won’t beat themselves up for having their regular ole’ feelings and thoughts and see you as the solution to humanity.
And without that, you don’t get to be the special amazing person who introduced them to who they REALLY are.
Damn.
Posted in Meditation, New Age thinking, sloppy thinking, spirituality | 7 Comments »
Tuesday, October 2nd, 2007
I loved bowling when I was a kid. If I couldn’t get a ride to the lanes from my parents, or the mom of a sometimes-friend (the time being “when I wanted to go bowling”), I would walk the 5 miles to the alley.
And if I didn’t have any money, I’d pick up trash around the parking lot in exchange for a couple of games.
And I’d watch bowling on TV whenever it was on — this was when bowling got prime time coverage.
Earl Anthony was one of the greats playing then. Earl was the first bowler to earn $1,000,000. He won 41 Professional Bowlers Association titles. I watched a lot of interviews with Earl… and not once did anyone ask him “How do you get bowling to carry over into your daily life?”
Bowling was something Earl did during the day, like eating, washing, driving, talking, and many other verbs. But I never heard Earl say anything like:
“Well, I was having a fight with my wife, but thanks to the replacement of the thumb-hole in my ball, and some added swing strength, I was able to resolve the tension faster than one of my perfect 300 point games!”
The idea that bowling would actually carry over into the other area of his life seems silly.
So, why do we think that it makes sense when people ask meditation teachers, “How do I integrate meditation into my daily life?”
The technical answer to the question is simple: Just meditate every day.
But that answer won’t suffice because it’s not addressing the real question, the question under the question, which is:
“Will meditating fix the parts of my life I don’t like?”
I want to have more money, have fewer fights with my family, and have a better job.
I want to get stuck in the grocery store line behind a guy trying to pay for each of his 25 items with a different credit card, and feel nothing but boundless love and compassion, rather than imagining how far up his colon those cards could go with the right broomstick to push them.
And I want to make these changes in my real life by using a technique developed by celibate monks who left the real world because it was an obstacle to their practice.
There was a period in Western meditation history, about 20 years ago, when many of the articles in magazines were from the teachers who were asking, “How is it that I’ve been meditating for decades, and had all these incredible experiences, and I still can’t hold a job, have a happy relationship, or enjoy good health?” I know more than a handful of meditation teachers who spent as much time in therapy as they did on their cushions.
I have a friend who is a big-deal Tibetan monk (btw, everyone should have a friend who’s a big deal in some religion — you get to hear first-hand about how the religion biz is not what most people think). He recently said to a group, “If you take almost all meditators out of their cave or monastery and put them in a shopping mall, they can’t calm their minds either.”
This notion that meditation is a cure for what (you think) ails you, rather than simply a skill, like bowling, seems to create a rash of unrealistic expectations… which will have to lead to disappointment when you’ve spent an hour in the Bliss of Emptiness, and then blow up at “Robert,” the Dell Tech Support guy who takes another hour asking you to repeat your service code before he can incorrectly diagnose your hard drive problem.
And, frankly, after talking to Robert, rather than meditating more with the hopes that you’ll handle it better next time, you might want to go hurl some bowling balls down the alley as hard as you can! There’s nothing like the sound of a strike.
Posted in Meditation, Self-Improvement, Spiritual Growth | 4 Comments »
Friday, September 28th, 2007
In many “spiritual” circles, they refer to two kinds of “truth”: Relative and Absolute.
Relative Truth is what we know and experience on a daily basis. There’s a you, there’s a me, we’re separate individuals. Events transpire over time. As the Zen boys would say, “Mountains are mountains and rivers are rivers.”
Absolute Truth on the other hand is when “Mountains are no longer mountains and rivers are no longer rivers.” Everything is an illusion. There is no separateness. We are all one. There is no time, no “I.” Nothing ever happens, nothing is born and nothing dies.
Some teachers suggest that the absolute is, well, absolute. That’s the only REAL reality. Because it’s, well, absolute!
Others have been saying, “Oh, no, life includes both the relative and the absolute.”
And while I wouldn’t disagree, their position is still a sales pitch for the absolute… because it’s still ABSOLUTE.
THE ABSOLUTE… well that sounds so much better, so much cooler. Who doesn’t want to see everything as a dream, to be one with all, to be timeless and spaceless and birthless deathless? I mean it’s ABSOLUTE. Clearly, Absolute is better than Relative. Why would you settle for anything less than Absolute?
The choice of language, of Absolute vs. Relative, is a set-up. It’s a come-on. It’s an enticement for buying a taste of Absolute.
Let’s pick new words. How ’bout: Juicy and Bubbly? Or Fred and Wilma? Or Chocolate and Peanut Butter? Or Crap and Shit?
If we use words with less connotative difference, or words that don’t set up an obvious and instantaneous preference, or words that are preferred as a pair, or words where neither are desired… well then we can have a conversation, an exploration, an honest investigation into the various and varying dimensions of human experience.
Neither is preferred. Neither is special. Neither is a problem. Neither is bad. Now there is one, now another… whatever.
“Mountains are once again mountains and rivers are once again rivers.”
Posted in Gurus, Meditation, Spiritual Growth | 4 Comments »
Saturday, September 22nd, 2007
I was given a popular meditation book recently.
Aside from the confusing fact that the cover blurb said, “The most American form of meditation,” yet the book taught basic Buddhist meditation practices, I was struck by the fundamental teaching:
Whatever arises, simply allow it to be.
Sounds like a great prescription for living, doesn’t it? Simply allow whatever arises to be. Mention this teaching to any adult, with or without a “spiritual” leaning, and they’ll agree that if they were better at allowing things to be, their life would be calmer, more relaxed, more successful.
There’s only one problem with this theory… it’s impossible (hence the 150+ pages about how to deal with the difficulties of meditation based on this teaching).
Why is it impossible? Well, just check your own experience:
Imagine some unpleasant sensation arises… you get a headache or your shoulders hurt, or you have pain in your chest after hearing a friend with cancer say they’ll cure it with The Secret.
Now, notice a somewhat obvious reality: the sensation is there, whether you want it to be or not!
You don’t have to allow it, it was already allowed before you even noticed it.
Or, try a thought. Repeatedly think something like “blue balloon,” and notice that it’s kind of fading away by the time you catch a glimpse of it. (BTW, this is not an esoteric notion. Many neuroscientists believe that our discursive thoughts are reporting an event that has already transpired.)
So, you don’t need to “allow it to be”. It’s already been!
This reminds me of times where someone shares what they think is the profound realization that to improve an interpersonal relationship, “I just need to let my mother/father/spouse/child/boss/pet be who they are.”
Guess what? They already are being who they are. That’s all they’ve been, all along. They don’t need your “allowing.” They’re not lying comatose in a mad scientist’s basement, unable to move until you “allow them to be.”\
This idea of “allowing” what has an independent existence (whether it’s a parent or a sensation) strikes me as radically arrogant. It’s like sitting by a train track thinking that your “allowing” is what lets the train move past you. Umm… the train is on the move, regardless of your allowing… just like your thoughts, your sensations and, frankly, most of the rest of your life.
Rather than attempting to allow something that already is, or was, though, here’s something to try. It think of it as “backing up a level”:
When some unpleasant thought/feeling/sensation arises that you wish were different… “allow” yourself to be okay with the fact that you want it to change. You may as well “allow” it, because it’s simply reality in that moment.
You’re sitting to meditate and your leg itches? Rather than “allowing the itch to be”, notice that your leg itches and you are wanting it to stop. “Allow” yourself to want it to stop… you might notice that your technique for trying to make it stop was “allowing it to be”.
Your partner leaves the toilet seat in whatever position it shouldn’t be in? Don’t try to “allow” them to be who they are. It’s too late. You’re already pissed. Start with that. “Allow” yourself one moment of it being okay that you’re pissed (not that you’re “right”, just that you wish they were different).
Paradoxically, if you back up to “allowing” the thing that’s honestly arising — the desire to change what you’re supposed allow to be — you may find a surprising “okay-ness” with the entire phenomenon — the thing you don’t like and your not liking it — regardless of whether it stays, leaves, changes, or anything else things can do.
I’ll allow you to try it, or not. And I’ll allow you to tell me what you discover, or not.
Posted in Meditation, Psychology, Self-Improvement, Spiritual Growth | 3 Comments »
Thursday, August 30th, 2007
My friend Robert Hover was one of the first westerners authorized to teach Buddhist meditation. This was about 45 years ago.
As part of Robert’s training with his teacher, U Ba Khin, he developed a particular way of attending to painful or unpleasant sensations that not only led to the discomfort disappearing but also resulted in some amazing physical and emotional healing (find out more at www.imhealing.com … but realize that Robert was an engineer; his writing is extremely accurate but sometimes tricky to understand).
Over time, more Westerners became meditation teachers. And as they encountered Robert teaching this incredible technique, they would criticize him, saying, “Meditation is about accepting things as they are, not trying to fix or change or improve them. It’s not about getting rid of the pain; it’s about accepting the pain as it is!”
Now, I know this sounds like a good argument, but there are a couple of serious problems with it.
First, nobody ever asked the critics this question: “Why would you want to accept the pain as it is?”
If they were rigorously honest, they would answer something like, “So I would be okay with it.” “So it wouldn’t bother me.” Or, if they were really honest, “So that it can change.”
In other words, the only reason you would want to “be with it” is if you want something — you or it — TO CHANGE!
(BTW, I find the same thing with Life Coaches who say their goal is to see their client as completely perfect… so that the client will then change.)
In fact, if you ask 99.9% of all meditators, “Why did you start meditating?” you’ll hear the story of what they wanted to change and why they wanted it to change. Whether it’s as mundane as “I wanted to learn to relax,” or as strong as, “I was suffering and I needed a way out,” or as arrogant as, “I want to become Awakened,” the bottom line is: What got them on the cushion, and what usually keeps them on, is the desire for something to be different.
I’ve noticed that for most meditators it gets harder and harder to notice this desire because it gets buried under the “I’m just accepting things as they are” story.
The second problem with criticizing Robert’s technique is similar to when fundamentalists picket a movie they haven’t seen (where’s the fun in that mental-ism?). Most of the critics never did Robert’s technique.
With Robert’s technique, you simply start with what’s true — “I have a pain I want to get rid of.” Simple. Accepting that you want to change things is a profound kind of acceptance!
In fact, Robert explains, pain itself increases the amount of energy you have to available to you, an amount of energy you can’t get if you’re not aware of some pain. And the desire to get rid of the pain is like the lens that focuses that energy.
As you use this focused, hightened energy to attend to your pain (rather than trying to ignore it, numb it, or “be with it until it leaves”) something strange happens. Almost out of nowhere, you leap way beyond “accepting the pain” or “being with it.” The very ideas of trying to change anything, or of “pain,” or “accepting” don’t even have room to arise as you focus your attention on the subtle sensations of your body/mind.
Interestingly, Robert believes that meditation is actually a tool developed to imitate this natural process of Pain > Energy > Focused Attention > Healing.
I spent a good 20 years telling myself that I was merely “being with” or “observing” my sensations or my breath (whichever meditation practice I was doing), while the meta-goal was to get rid of the unpleasantness in my life. Didn’t work so good.
Then I stopped. I just couldn’t make myself believe that I needed to be different or “better.”
The next time I did a meditation course (14 hours/day for 10 days), someone said, “It looked like this was an easy course for you.” I replied, “When you’re not trying to accomplish anything, how hard is it to just sit on your butt?”
Eventually, as I could feel that my entire motivation to meditate was based on thinking it would improve me — and noticing how crappy that idea made me feel — I quit. From 2 hours/day to nothing. Cold turkey. Except instead of having withdrawal pains, I felt great! And why wouldn’t I? I stopped spending 2 hours a day subtly reminding myself that there was something wrong with me!
Four years later, it popped into my head to meditate.
“Oh, this won’t be very good,” I thought, remembering how it took some time and practice to really get that meditation ball rolling. “Well, whatever.” I sat on my cushion, closed my eyes, and had one of the “deepest” sessions I’d ever experienced.
When I wasn’t trying to improve myself by “accepting things as they were” that inner world was VERY interesting 😉
(and, what happened next is what became the Instant Advanced Meditation Course)
[tags]meditation, vipassana, U Ba Khin, Buddhism[/tags]
Posted in Gurus, Meditation, Self-Improvement, Spiritual Growth | 15 Comments »
Friday, May 18th, 2007
I have a friend who meditates for a living.
Yup. Gets paid to sit on his butt.
He’s living in Fairfield, Iowa, the US home of TM (Trancendental Meditation).
Apparenly, some gajillionaire (I think he actually has gajillion dollar bills!) believes that if enough TM people meditate (long, hard, with feeling, without feeling… something) enough, then they can change the course of human affairs and make the world a better place.
Don’t try to tell me that it’s true… or that it’s not. That’s not important.
What’s important, and what I love about this experiment is this: There’s no way they can lose!
If something — anything — changes in the world in what someone calls a “better” direction, they can say, “See, we did that by sitting on our butts!”
And if nothing changes, then that simply “proves” that the world simply needs more, better, faster, stronger, butt sitters.
You know that question, “Would you rather be happy or right?” Well, with a setup like this one, where you can be right no matter what… you could be very both!
I’m glad this guy has gajillions to spend.
Posted in Gurus, Meditation | 3 Comments »
Friday, November 17th, 2006
My favorite thing about the title of this blog post is that it might get some people a bit hot under the meditation cushion, but it’s not too likely to get my website firebombed. However, had I replaced Buddha with Jesus or Mohammed… well, that could lead to a whole different set of consequences.
And what’s most interesting to me about that is what Buddha, Jesus and Mohammed all have in common is:
They are a collection of lines and squiggles that people interpret into sounds, add meaning to them and then act in some way based on what they think the person who created the lines and squiggles meant.
Silly humans.
Anyway, back to the Buddha sucking…
So, many people engage in meditative practice to achieve the goal of awakening or enlightenment. And they turn to their various teachers and books and tapes and workshops and retreats to travel down the “spiritual path.”
Now, I’m not going to argue about the validity of the motive or the existence of the goal or the reality of some sort of path. Instead, let’s just take a look at the success rate of one of the greatest teachers and his students.
The Buddha is often called “The Great Doctor,” because it’s said that he taught 84,000 different people and gave each one of them their own unique meditation technique because he could see exactly and perfectly what they needed to attain awakening.
First things first. In the area that the Buddha had influence over during the 45 years of his teaching, there were approximately 5 million people. So this tremendously powerful teacher only got to about 1.7% of the people in his neighborhood.
Leaving that alone for a second, let’s look back at the 84k who decided they wanted to hear what the ochre-robed one had to say. According to the texts, there were 500 “Arahants”, five hundred people who “Got it” (they are, it’s said, the ones who codified the Buddha’s teaching after the Buddha died).
So, 500 people who reached the goal. Five hundred who got the brass ring.
Five hundred out of EIGHTY FOUR THOUSAND.
Let’s to the math, shall we?
500 out of 84,000 is just less than 0.60% …
The greatest teacher that ever was, according to Buddhists, had a success rate of barely more than one half of one percent.
I don’t know about you, but there aren’t many things I’d put a lot of energy into with those kinds of odds.
Now, granted, if we were all living 2500 years ago in Northern India, there’s no way of knowing if you, me or your noisy neighbor would have been one of the 500… and there’s no way to know now.
As my friend, the meditation teacher Robert Hover, said to me, “The number of beings who must conspire to allow for your awakening is so vast as to be unknowable… so you may as well assume it’ll happen because that’s just more fun… but it’s completely out of your control.”
Kinda takes the pressure off, doesn’t it? 😉
Posted in Gurus, Meditation, Spiritual Growth, Uncategorized | 15 Comments »
Monday, October 2nd, 2006
WARNING: This will be an unusually short post for me 😉
I already talked about this particular issue, so I don’t need to rehash it. But I ran across the PERFECT example of it, so I had to bring it up again.
So… There’s a new movie called Milarepa: Magician, Murderer, Saint directed by a big-deal Tibetan Buddhist (who was actually born in Bhutan), named Netan Chockling Rinpoche.
(By the way, I’m not trying to be facetious when I say “big-deal”… he is an well known and respected teacher/practioner.)
In an interview that appeared in my local newspaper, Rinpoche described the story:
Milarepa’s mother was so tempted by revenge that she sent her son to sorcery school so he could punish his greedy aunt and uncle by conjuring up an epic storm that flattened their village.
Later, though:
Milarepa lears that revenge isn’t the answer and becomes one of the great sages of Tibetan Buddhism.
Now, here’s the fun part. Get ready:
“Milarepa is really a normal guy — nothing special,” Rinpoche says. “If he can do it [become a Saint], anybody can do it.”
Okay, hit the pause button.
He’s a normal guy?
Hel-lo-o?
When’s the last time you developed the skill to create a storm out of thin air, point it an a village, and turn it into something that looks like the floor of Spring Break bar at 5:00 am?
In fact, in the Tibetan tradition Milarepa is not just a conjurer, but one of the GREATEST conjurers. He isn’t just a murderer, but a… well, if one wants to murder and is successful at that mission, does that make them a GREAT murderer?
Does that sound like a “normal guy” to you?
When someone gives us one of these Horatio-Alger-pull-yourself-up-from-the-gutter-anyone-can-be-president-(or-enlightened) stories. We just nod our heads like bobble-head dolls. We love these stories. They confirm our greatest hopes. They play right into our desire to ensure our happiness by controlling the the universe in some way.
But come on. Seriously. If someone said, “Tiger Woods was just a kid with parents; if he could become one of the greatest golfers of all time, so can you!” or “Really, Bill Gates dropped out of college; if he can become the richest man in the world, so can you!” or “George Bush… he was a C student, alcoholic, coke snorting…” okay well maybe that’s not a good example. But you get my point.
You wouldn’t use thes rare examples as proof that YOU can be that… they’re RARE… that’s WHY we find them fascinating! They’re proof that humans can do amazing things sometimes, but not that YOU can do it simply because it’s possible.
Tiger Woods can’t run a 4-minute mile. Bill Gates can’t stack cups in a 3-6-3 6-6 1-10-1 speed stack set in 7.5 seconds (http://speedstacks.com/videos.htm if you don’t know what I’m talking about… I LOVE this “sport”). George Bush can’t… again, I’m not going there.
I don’t know about you, but when I hear the Milarepa story and tilt my head with a curious, Hmmmm… I no longer think I can imitate Milarepa. I see that he’s a, well, let’s just say he’s unique.
But so am I and so is everyone else. I don’t have a clue where my “path” will lead and, frankly, I don’t much care since I don’t really believe in paths.
But I have a hunch it’ll be a better ride if I’m not thinking Milarepa is an example of how mine will/could/should be and comparing what I imagine my life to be to what I imagine his life to have been.
Off to make sure it doesn’t rain on me while I’m in the hot tub…
[tags]spirituality, spiritual growth, gurus[/tags]
Posted in Gurus, Meditation, Self-Improvement, Spiritual Growth | 1 Comment »
Wednesday, September 27th, 2006
“It’s all an illusion.”
“Nothing has ever happened to nobody.”
“Everything is just the play of consciousness.”
Sounds cool, yeah? Core, essential, pithy truths, right?
Sure, if you nod your head and believe everything you hear just because it feels good.
You may have statements like these on your fridge or on posters on the wall or in needlepoint wall hangings… maybe, you believe, if you remind yourself of these ideas for long enough, you’ll actually experience them 24/7. Maybe.
But, here’s the big question:
Are they even true?!
Is everything REALLY just an illusion so compelling that, well, it seems real?
I’ve hung out with a lot of teachers who say things like this. And I always wonder the same thing when I hear them say it:
Why can’t they PROVE it? Why don’t they do something that demonstrates that these ideas are more than mere concepts?
Why don’t we ever see one of these teachers stand in the middle of the highway letting illusiory cars pass through their fictitious bodies?
Why do they pay taxes, eat food, get liposuction?
And why do so many of these teachers who say “nothing ever happened to nobody” all tell you the time and date that this “nothing” happened… and why do their “nobody’s” often have funny Buddhist/Hindu/Pleadian names?
So, which seems more likely: that it’s all an illusion, or that “it’s all an illusion” is just how someone impresses you by using mystical-poetic language to describe a description-defying experience?
What if you didn’t think that it was a worthwhile goal to attain the “level of consciousness” you believe has been reached by those who talk this way? What if you didn’t think that seeing it all as “a play of illusion” would make you happier, thinner, or make people pay money to hear you talk?
Here’s a quick lesson from Buddhism about this “nobody” thing: There’s no such “thing” a chair — chair is a concept we use when encounter a combination of independent parts (“legs”, “seat”, “back”)… and those independent parts are combinations of other independent… and so on, and so on and so on. No matter how far you look, you never find a chair separate from the concept of chair.
Scientists say something similar… they can’t find (or agree upon) what the essential unit of matter is. Each “thing” they find is either made up of other things or has qualities that aren’t fixed in time and space. When examined from a particular perspective, they can’t find some stable “thing.”
Same thing with “Me”. “Me” is just a word to describe a process, a relationship, an experience. You can’t find some specific aspect of “me” that is, well, you. At best, you may land on the simple feeling/sensation/experience of your undeniable existence… but you’ll be hard pressed to define that experience/feeling/sensation… unless you resort to the poetic language you heard from someone else that’s the closest match you can find to that phenomenon.
Not being able to find an inherent “somebody” does not mean that what exists instead is a “nobody.”
Having an experience where one perceives all formation arising from a vast un-name-able something and receding back into it — the way a wave seemingly arises and passes away while never being anything other than the ocean — does not mean that “nothing ever happens.” It’s merely a coarse description of one way of perceiving reality… one of many.
In Kabbalah, for example, ALL of the ways of describing reality are simultaneously accurate — the interaction of independent parts, the interplay of related phenomenon, the ebb and flow of one essential core component, and something that completely defies being described .
Ironically, saying it’s all an illusion is a way of giving solidity to the thing. It freezes the ocean into a knowable, definable, thing.
But if it is, truly, an illusion, even the idea that YOU perceive that IT is a THING (an illusion) is an illusion too.
And if that’s true, what’s left? What do you see when you look out the window without the idea that it’s REAL *or* that it’s an ILLUSION.
Look, just for fun, and see what you see without the stories that we use to understand it all.
And then, if you want to have real fun, turn your attention to the “thing” that was perceiving (or receiving or whatever it was doing) what you were looking at.
And if you want to enjoy the biggest secret, don’t put a name or label on what you find. If someone asks, tell the ruthless (and probably wordless) truth.
[tags]meditation, spiritual growth, psychology, self-improvement[/tags]
Posted in Meditation, Self-Improvement, Spiritual Growth | 4 Comments »
Saturday, September 9th, 2006
In January of ’06, my wife and and were in Mumbai, India (as if there’s another Mumbai you would confuse it with. “Does he mean Mumbai, Kentucky?”) for a friend’s wedding. And, btw, if you ever hava a chance to go to India I can’t recommend enough going for a wedding put on by a well-to-do Indian family. But that’s another story.
Knowing that we’d be in Mumbai, a couple of big-time spiritual seeker friends (that is, they’re searching big-time and they’re well-known for doing it) said, “Oh, you must meet Ramesh Balsekar when you’re there… here’s his phone number.”
Ramesh is a former president of the Bank of India who, for the last 20+ (maybe 30+) years has camped out in a chair in a corner of a room in his million-dollar flat and, at 9:00 am sharp (the only thing that started on time in India) taught/lectured to the mostly-Western seekers who squeeze into the tiny room.
What does he teach? Well, he’s in the lineage of the Advaita (“not-two”) Vedanta teachers, Ramana Maharshi and Nisagardatta Maharaj, if that means anything to you. If not, perhaps what happened at the very end of the 3-hour meeting will ‘splain it.
But before I get to that part, I want to tell you how weird it was to be crammed into a tiny room in downtown Mumbai with 30 people — some 1st timers and some who’ve been in the same room every day for months or years — who really wanted something that, they thought would make them happy finally. The weird part wasn’t all the wanting, it was that I’ve been in the exact same room in Boulder, in Santa Fe, in Marin in Boston, in… EVERYWHERE.
I don’t know why I imagined that with a bona-fide “Indian spiritual teacher” in India would be different than what I’ve seen (and grown weary of) everywhere else I’ve travelled but, oh well, here it was again.
So check this out. Ramesh starts out by saying, “If you believe that by becoming ‘enlightened’ you will become free of unpleasant experiences or emotions, you’re mistaken. You will not get special powers, your personality will not change to that of a saint, you will not become well-liked or loved, you will not live in some imagined state of bliss. You will get nothing. Nothing.”
I laughed, thinking of all the times I nodded my head at the idea that spiritual growth or it’s goal, awakening, would give me ALL of what he just described (and how, after no longer nodding at that idea, I was happier than I ever was when I was on “the path” to get, well, happy). But nobody else was laughing. They were all deadly serious, as if they were waiting for Ramesh to become a California teenager and reveal that he was kidding with a big, “NOT!”
But Ramesh wasn’t kidding.
Why didn’t everyone stand up and leave, I wondered. The only reason I stayed was I was curious to see how he followed this great take-away… and that I had come with someone who I saw was now ready for the teaching about how to get everything Ramesh said you wouldn’t get!
Okay, so at the one hour mark, someone asked, “How did you come to this realization you have?” Ramesh replied, “Oh, I was born with the understanding of determinism in my blood.”
I looked around the room again, to see if anyone really heard what he just said. The guy — the “teacher” — just said that he didn’t do anything to become whatever or whoever he is, that he was just born this way. It was his natural tendency, his innate something-or-other. Something that was completely out of his control. Again, I couldn’t for the life of my figure out why half the room didn’t stand up and leave — after all, if he did NOTHING to get what you think you want, why do you think you can do something to get it?
Well, Ramesh is a pretty funny guy (though I seemed to be the only one laughing at the jokes), so I stuck with it.
Finally, as things are about to wrap up, I said, “Can I try to sum up what you’ve been saying for the last few hours?” “Certainly,” Ramesh replied staring me down.”
“Okay, there’s a thing you’re calling ‘enlightenment’ which you describe as the 100% complete conviction and understanding that there is no inherent ‘do-er’ in our life. That we are not the instigators of our thoughts and actions but, instead, we and everything about us is merely an expression of some un-name-able something which is all of existence.”
He nods. I continue.
“So, if there is no ‘person’ who is doing any thing, if we are not the causes but, instead, the effects… then there’s nothing we can do to make this understanding/awakening thing happen. No amount of meditating, no amount of spiritual practice, no amount of sitting here with Ramesh Balsekar will guarantee it happening, or accelerate when it happens. And no amount of not practicing or acting ‘non-spiritually’ will keep it away. If it’s going to happen, it’ll happen and if not, then not. And there’s nothing to do be done about it either way.”
“YES! That’s it,” he laughed… and I laughed with him… but I looked around the room and nobody else was laughing. In fact, they all looked like they were thinking “If I could really understand that point, then that would lead to my enlightenment!”
Oh, well.
“If you want something to do while you’re waiting to see if it happens or not, I have something for you,” Ramesh offered to the group. “At the end of the day, sit down and relax — if you need a beer or two to relax, do that. Then think of something you did that day, something you know that you did, something where you know you had control over it… and then examine that carefully.”
This is very similar to something I teach people to do (something I picked up from my friend Byron Katie). Take a look at all the things you do without any awareness at all? Did you consciously decide to put your arms or legs in that position? And if so, take a look at the thought that preceded your action? Did you make that thought happen? Were you sitting around doing nothing, and think, “Okay, I’ll have the thought about going to get some ice cream in … 5… 4… 3… 2… and NOW!” or did you just notice that you had the thought? Or notice that you must have had the thought because you now find yourself on the way to get some Chunky Monkey?
If you force yourself to think about an elephant, did you consciously make it exactly that size, that color? Did you plan to put those rough hairs on the elephant’s feet (or had you not even thought about it until I said it, at which point it showed up, fully formed without any effort)?
“Do this for about 30 minutes each night,” Ramesh suggested. And one day, you’ll be blinded by the total, complete understanding… and it’ll all be done.
Oh, crap. When push comes to shove, even the guy who spent 3 hours (and 30+ years) saying there’s nothing to do that will get you where you think you want to go, gives something to do to get you there! Hmmm…
As I was leaving, some of the “regulars” stopped me to say hello. “It was so nice to have you here. To hear someone laughing and bringing your energy; we’re glad you made it.” “Thanks,” I said, “it was fun.”
“Are you coming back?” they asked.
I was a bit shocked by the question.
“Why? Didn’t you hear what he said? It’s all taken care of. No reason to come back or not come back. He’s a nice, smart, funny old guy, but I’m here for a wedding. I’ve got shopping and eating to do.”
They looked like they kinda got what I was saying but couldn’t quite believe I’d pass up the oppurtunity to hang out with a guy who admits there’s no reason or benefit for hanging out with him.
In fact, I noticed that while all the seekers where hanging out in the foyer, Ramesh was just wandering around the flat. So, I walked back to say hello and thank him for an entertaining morning. He gave me a big hug, showed me around the place, and we had a picture taken of the two of us. Cute old guy.
BTW, did you notice the little bombshell Ramesh dropped (and I mentioned) about determinism? That’s his big thing. Not only is there nobody doing anything, but it’s all pre-determined. If you were supposed to become enlightened (or a good golfer, or the one who should be fighting with his spouse over money), then it will happen to you. It’s pre-determined so there’s nothing you can do about it. Once you understand that, he says, there’s on need for guilt or blame or shame because you’re all merely doing what God set you up to do.
I won’t get into all the problems with this line of thinking, but I will point out 2 simple ones:
First, if you’re not the one running your life, you don’t need some mega-being who is. Life can unfold with probabilities and chance and randomness just fine. It doesn’t need a universal map that accounts for the position of every particle over all time.
Related to that is #2: If your life is merely the play of some pre-determined plan, then so are the lives of your parents, and their’s and so on and so on… follow that back long enough and you will either never find an initial cause, a moment that set everything else in motion… or you will conclude that there was one moment, BILLIONS of years ago, when the great Planner in the Sky decided what time this morning you would go to the toilet.
While I find determinism a bit more close to my actual experience (especially when I notice that I did nothing to have the thought “Time to write about Ramesh now”), it’s also yet another belief I can nod my head at as a way to add some “meaning” to a life that is much more rich, fun, and full of possibilities without this theory.
Posted in Gurus, Meditation, Self-Improvement, Spiritual Growth | 87 Comments »
Saturday, August 26th, 2006
No, I’m not proposing a new reality show where we put 10 meditators in a room, issue concentration challenges to them, and see who America votes for as the best meditator (though, now that I write it… nah, never mind).
What I want to talk about today is the problem with monks and meditators.
Not a problem with them as people or as practitioners.
But a problem with them as examples, as role models, as “proof” that the spiritual path reliably leads to where you want to go.
Now I’m not even going to touch the phenomenon of spiritual teachers and leaders who, it turns out, have been sleeping with their students while preaching celibacy, or stealing money while claiming poverty, or eating frozen burritos right out of the 7-Eleven freezer at 3:00 am after years of subsisting on nothing but “universal energy” (it was amazing to watch this “breatharian” try to explain away the security video showing him doing this).
What I want to look at is the honest-to-goodness, insightful, peaceful, clear-minded, level-headed men and women who spent their life in spiritual pursuits. These people (rare as they are) are the ones we admire, the ones we hope to emulate. They’re the ones who give us confidence that all the time we spend watching our breath, or praying, or doing good works, or going to workshops, or buying angel posters is not for naught.
But should we be reassured by them at all? Does their life actually demonstrate something relevant for us?
A few weeks ago, I spent some time with a good friend who also happens to be a high-ranking Tibetan monk. During one conversation, we talked about how most of the young men who entered the monastery with him had long ago removed their robes and gone onto mundane lives. There were relatively few who had been in monastic life as long as my friend, and he’s only in his late 30’s.
By the time he’s in his 50’s or 60’s or 80’s — assuming he hasn’t replaced his robes with blue jeans by then — even fewer of his monastic brothers will still be in the monk business (one thing you learn from hanging out with leaders of religious orders is how much of a business it is).
In other words, as time goes on, there are fewer and fewer “survivors” still in the game.
It’s the same in any business or endeavor. Over time, some stay, some fall away.
By definition, the ones still standing at the end are a rare and unusual breed.
But, when we look at or to these people, we seem to forget how unusual they are (or get angry when they engage in one of those infractions I mentioned and find out how un-unusual they are!).
Looking at the rare survivors as if they are typical is what behavioral economists and cognitive psychologists call “survivorship bias.” We have a natural tendency to look at the people who’ve “made it”, who’ve gotten what we think we want, and believe we can get what they got if we just do what we think they did. We overlook the significantly larger number of non-survivors, most of whom are much more like us.
In other words, what I realized when I talked to my monk friend without nodding my head is that the we only hear from the spiritual survivors, the rare beings who, for reasons that we may never know, are still standing. And then we compare ourselves to them… And this is where the suffering begins.
But once we recognize that they are just the survivors. Once we stop nodding at the idea that we can simply do what they did and get what they (ostensibly) got, things get pretty interesting.
Rather than proving long-term spiritual practice leads to certain attainments, it’s just as likely that the people who have a propensity for certain attainments also have a leaning toward doing long-term spiritual practice.
Look at your own life for examples of this: Did you ever start a sport or a hobby and then stop when it became clear that there were some people who were just naturally gifted and that you would never be as good as them? My running career ended in 9th grade when all the other sprinters suddenly grew to 6′ and I barely made it to 5’6″ — no amount of passion or training would overcome their physiological advantage. And then the tall group separated themselves when it became clear that, well, some guys are just plain faster.
Many people I meet tell me how they need to meditate more, or better, or whatever, citing the example of some teacher who says “The only way to get what I have is to do what I do — 10 hours a day!”
Maybe. Maybe not.
Maybe you could do 20 hours a day and not get “there”, because they just happen to be “faster.”
Or, maybe they have misapprehended their own life and believe that the 10 hour/day practice is what made them who they are… but, maybe being someone who would even consider a 10 hour/day practice is someone who, with 1 minute a day, would have gotten to the same place (looking over history and assuming we can identify the causes that led to the present is what cognitive psych and behavioral finance guys call “hindsight bias”).
If we aren’t aware of how survivorship bias affects our thinking, we could put ourselves in some situations that we hope would lead to happiness, but get or infer information that points us in the exact opposite direction.
Without understanding survivorship bias, we could 1000 people play Russian Roulette and, when there was only one person still standing ask him, “What’s your secret to success?!”
“Simple,” he’d reply, “you just pull the trigger and don’t shoot yourself!”
Posted in Evolutionary Psychology, Gurus, Meditation, Spiritual Growth, Uncategorized | Comments Off on Last Meditator Standing… or Survivor, Tibet
Thursday, August 17th, 2006
I don’t make an effort, but when I see Bill Moyers’ show, Faith and Reason, on my Tivo, I’ll watch it. I spent so many years listening to spiritual teachers and, well, old habits are hard to break. So far, I haven’t been able to make it through an episode. I hear a lot about faith, but not so much about reason. Or, more accurately, I hear reason that, at some point, hits its limit, and then is replaced my major leaps of logic that are called faith.
Anyway, the Western-born Tibetan Buddhist Nun, Pema Chodron, was on the other day. I used to really enjoy her writing, but I hadn’t read anything of her’s since I stopped nodding my head (see the first post). And, back in my nodding days, I nodded a lot at various Buddhist ideas.
Watching Pema Chodron, it was as if a Buddhist veil had fallen off of my head when I began tilting it. Let me tell you what I mean.
I only saw the second half of the interview (my Tivo is set to record the whole thing if it’s ever replayed), but in that 30 minutes, Pema said 3 things that floored me:
- She sees the Buddha as a role model because he’s an ordinary human who achieved “awakening.”Now this is the common idea about the Buddha in the West. In the East, most Buddhists think of the Buddha as a god. “Lord Buddha” isn’t just an honorific over there. But, more importantly, when you read the Buddhist stories, the “he’s just a guy” idea doesn’t hold water.Ignore for a moment the uniqueness of his life — born the son of the king of the Sakya clan, raised without seeing suffering, experiencing the best that his father could offer. The same teachers that say “he’s just a man” also tell the stories of his past lives, the hundreds of thousands of lives where he demonstrated almost super-human levels of compassion, insight, wisdom, intelligence, generosity, etc. It’s said that all those lifetimes prepared him to become awakened, to become the Buddha. And the Buddhist teachings also talk about how rarely an awakened one appears in the world.Does that sound like an ordinary guy?Michael Jordan is an ordinary guy. But nobody thinks that by practicing basketball for a few hours a day they’ll become one of the rarest basketball talents is the world. Tiger Woods is just a man, but nobody thinks that — with any amount of practice — they will become the next Tiger Woods.
So why do we think that we can and will like someone who, by definition, is an unfathomably rare individual?
And, hey, I’m not saying we won’t. I don’t know. (At some point, I’ll write the Kabbalistic story about how we *could* be that one and not know it).
But look at what it costs to hold a unique and rare individual as a model… when our lives don’t seem to compare to it. When, no matter how much we meditate or pray or chant, we still get angry in traffic, or confused by our spouse, or frustrated at, well, anything.
Related to this is…
- Pema Chodren said she has faith that all beings have the potential for awakening.Sounds good, but then Bill asked, “Are you awakened?” She laughed at the seeming absurdity of the question. “No,” she said.Now, this is a woman who has been “practicing” Buddhist meditation for over 30 years. She’s a Buddhist nun. She hasn’t “gotten it,” but everyone has the potential to?Sure, given enough time, enough lifetimes, it seems possible. I’m all for it. But Buddhism promises “enlightenment” (and other religions promise something similar or the same). The question is: Where is the evidence that it delivers what it promises?
Where are all the enlightened beings who are no longer “practicing” because they’re playing (the game, the music, or whatever else you practice for)?
Again, reading the Buddhist texts, the Buddha taught 84,000 people and only 500 “got it” (and they became awake, but NOT Buddhas… they still had many of the personality traits that most practitioners hope will go vanish in the light of enlightenment). He was the best teacher there was and only .6% of his students got the gold ring.
Tibetan Buddhists like to say that what makes their version of Buddhism unique (and better than Zen or Theravada) is that it promises awakening in one lifetime. Then the obvious question is: Why aren’t all practitioners of Tibetan Buddhism enlightened?
Before you answer something like, “Not everyone practices well enough,” I’ll ask, “How can you really know what’s going on in someone’s head, in someone’s practice?” I’m sure I’ll write about how we can’t use end results as a “proof” for undefinable causes, like how well you concentrate, how much you want something, or what your “vibration” is.
Maybe the better question is: If there are any who did become enlightened, was it REALLY a result of their practice or was a bigger factor something like past lives or eating Mexican food or some other factor that we can’t know or can’t quantify?
- Finally, and perhaps most importantly, Bill quoted the Zen teacher, Suzuki Roshi, who once said to his students, “You’re all perfect; and you need some improvement.”Pema Chodren nodded in agreement with that one. It’s a great line. It points to the paradox of unity and duality. Genuinely understood, it’s a show stopper. But think about how we normally hear that statement.Normally, we REALLY BELIEVE the second part, and HOPE TO EVENTUALLY REALLY BELIEVE the first part… after we finish improving ourselves. We give lip service to the idea that we’re perfect, fine, showing up exactly as we should be. But we spend countless hours, dollars and energy attending to our self-improvement project.
This line — we’re perfect and need improvement — and that we don’t really experience the perfection but do experience the idea of needing improvement, is the motor that drives a multi-billion dollar improvement industry. It’s what keeps us in annoyingly lit hotel rooms for a weekend instead of enjoying a day in the park with our loved ones. It’s what motivates us to engage in all sorts of practices that subtly reinforce the idea of our being broken while simlutaneously letting us think we’re better than others who aren’t “on the path.”
So, how do I put all this together?
Without the idea that there’s some ideal person to emulate, that there’s some practice that will get me to become that person, that in this imagined “awakened” future I can finally be happy… without all of those ideas? Guess what? Perfection. Here. Now. Really.
Not “perfection” as in: the best, the smartest, only having the thoughts I want, etc. That’s perfection COMPARED to imperfection.
Instead, without nodding my head at the notion of being an improvement project, it (and by “it” I mean “me) is genuinely fine, exactly as it is. I can see how every movement of my life, and my parents’ lives, and their parents’, and so on all the way to the beginning of time, led inexorably to this moment. How dare I suggest I think I know how it could/should be “better.”
And, if I wake up in the morning with the idea of exercising or meditating or chanting or whatever… it’s not about improving this thing I’ll call me. It’s just what this me thing does as an expression of… well, there’s no word that can even fill that place in the sentence.
Okay, it’s done. Off to what’s next.
Posted in Gurus, Meditation, Psychology, Self-Improvement, Spiritual Growth | 4 Comments »
Monday, August 14th, 2006
I hopped in a car to ride down the spiritual path at the age of 7. By 10 I was comparing notes with 63 year old physicians on the clinical application of hypnosis for anaesthesia and pain relief.
And off it went from there… biofeedback, Vedanta, Shaivism, Tai Chi, Aikido, Taoism, Vipassana, Zen and Tibetan Buddhism, Kabbalah, and Western therapies and workshops of all kinds.
I wasn’t just a student. I became a teacher in many of these diciplines.
And, no matter where I went, no matter what I did, I would nod my head at the fundamental promise:
If I followed these teachers and/or teachings, I would eventually get what I wanted — happiness, spiritual attainment, peace of mind, awakening, realization, enlightenment. Pick the word, I wanted it.
One day, after 28 years travelling on the path, with no end in sight (and not many examples of people who had reached the goal) I stopped nodding my head and, instead, I began “tilting my head.”
Almost literally, instead of nodding in agreement, I took on the attitude of “Hmm…? What’s really going on here? Is it true?”
Since that moment, my life has never been the same.
And, perhaps, when you hear what I’ve discovered since then, your’s won’t be either.
Enjoy.
Posted in Evolutionary Psychology, Gurus, Meditation, Psychology, Self-Improvement, Spiritual Growth | 1 Comment »
|